Wait, What’s a PBM?


Pharmacy profit managers, or PBMs, are middleman corporations that negotiate the worth of pharmaceuticals. PBMs are on the middle of a tangled knot of pharmacies, drugmakers, and well being insurers.

Consultants say they play an enormous function in elevating prescription drug costs.

On this episode of “An Arm and a Leg,” host Dan Weissmann explores how PBMs work and appears into authorities efforts to verify their energy. Since this episode initially aired in 2019, widespread laws to control PBMs has been launched on the state degree. Weissmann provides an replace.

Beforehand, Dan was a workers reporter for Market and Chicago’s WBEZ. His work additionally seems on All Issues Thought of, Market, the BBC, 99 P.c Invisible, and Reveal, from the Heart for Investigative Reporting.

Word: “An Arm and a Leg” makes use of speech-recognition software program to generate transcripts, which can comprise errors. Please use the transcript as a instrument however verify the corresponding audio earlier than quoting the podcast.

Dan: Hey there —

You will have seen advertisements just lately about entry to medication. Right here’s one which begins with a lady making an attempt to fill a prescription, however the pharmacist says…

[Clip from an ad plays]

Pharmacist: I’m sorry, this drugs isn’t lined by your insurance coverage.

PBM: Yeah…

Dan: This man in a blue go well with comes up from behind. The affected person grabs her prescription slip.

[Ad clip resumes]

PBM: I resolve which medicines you will get.

Affected person: Wait, you’re not my physician.

PBM: That’s proper, I’m your insurance coverage firm’s pharmacy profit supervisor, or PBM. And, I don’t make as a lot cash off this one.

Dan: You may marvel, wait, what’s a PBM precisely? And in addition, why am I seeing this advert now?

And who’s paying for this advert? So PBMs are intermediary corporations which have so much to do with which medication we get entry to, how a lot we pay for them, and yeah, they’re sharks. And, these advertisements are on the market as a result of Congress is aware of we’re all mad about drug costs and entry to medication, and so they’re desperate to be seen doing one thing about it.

And people advertisements are paid for by pharmaceutical makers — additionally sharks — in direct competitors with PBMs for the gazillions of {dollars} we spend on medication as a rustic. PBMs and their function are a bit extra difficult, so we’re bringing again an episode from this present’s very early days. After we get to the tip, I’ll have some updates, issues I’ve discovered since then.

In the meantime, right here’s me 4 years in the past, beginning to determine how all this works.

So firstly of the 12 months, my household switched to a brand new medical health insurance plan and I’ve obtained this prescription I take. I get three months price of it at a time, and in February it was time to resume. The pharmacy texted me they’d it. I known as to verify, obtained the robotic voice.

Robotic: There’s one prescription right here for Daniel

Dan: And a few information.

Robotic: The out-of-pocket value is $720.69. And that’s prepared for pickup.

Dan: I used to be like, what? That is an old-time generic drug. I’m used to paying like 15 bucks.

Robotic: Would you want me to repeat that?

Dan: I used to be like, perhaps you higher. I need this on tape.

Robotic: The out-of-pocket value is $720.69.

[Robot voice fades into the background]

Dan: I used to be additionally like, yeah, I’m simply gonna carry my new insurance coverage card over to the pharmacy and hope that clears issues up.

And it did. The copay was $0. That’s some good new insurance coverage proper there. And as I walked outta the drug retailer, I used to be like, What was that each one about? I pulled up a web site known as GoodRx on my cellphone. A physician pal of mine typically recommends it to individuals whose prescriptions value so much, and what I discovered there was bizarre.

I punched within the title of the treatment and my zip code and it confirmed me costs from a bunch of various locations. Drugstore chains like CVS and Walgreens, large field shops like Costco and Walmart, native supermarkets with pharmacy counters. And the unfold was loopy. 25 bucks at Costco, 170 on the grocery store, 300-some at CVS, and greater than 700 at my drugstore, Walgreens.

And that was simply the primary set of costs. There have been truly two. The primary: what you’d pay for those who simply walked in. The second was what you’d pay at every place for those who introduced in a digital coupon from GoodRx. And with the coupons, one other loopy unfold, a bunch of $20 choices. However 75 bucks at CVS, 195 at Walgreens.

And this was simply tremendous, tremendous bizarre. And it meant I used to be gonna should do one thing I’d been actually form of dreading… Determining prescription drug costs. I’d accomplished some studying about it earlier than and it all the time made my eyes glaze over. I used to be like, ah, no. Too difficult. Let me come again to this, like in another lifetime.

However this was too bizarre to not examine. As a result of I used to be used to seeing tales about excessive drug costs. I figured all of us knew that, however I wasn’t used to seeing tales about random costs. That was new. Higher get on that. That is An Arm and a Leg, a present about the price of well being care. I’m Dan Weissmann.

And I did some studying and finally I discovered tips on how to perhaps clarify this to myself with out getting completely misplaced.

And I ended up operating this rationalization by some consultants and so they all stated, that’s not essentially the most idiotic rationalization. So right here goes. It begins with the outdated film It’s a Great Life. Proper firstly of the film, the Jimmy Stewart character, George Bailey, is a 12-year-old child working within the drugstore.

Now, be aware the sound impact right here from this scene. Clip clap. That is olden days, 1919. And within the scene, the child retains the pharmacist, Mr. Gower, from sending out literal poison drugs.

Movie sound: Mr. Gower, you don’t know what you’re doing. You, you set one thing dangerous in these capsules. It wasn’t your fault, Mr. Gower, simply look and see what you probably did. The bottle took the powder from… it’s poison, I inform you, it’s poison.

Dan: Now late within the film, there’s a scene with one other character, a very grouchy bartender.

Movie sound: Hey, look, mister. We save exhausting drinks in right here for males who wanna get drunk quick, and we don’t want any characters round to offer the joint ambiance. Is that clear or do I’ve to slide you my left for a convincer?

Dan: And right here’s the factor. On the time of those scenes, the druggist and the bartender had been mainly in the identical form of enterprise. I’m speaking in regards to the construction of the enterprise. You go to the bar, order a martini, the man grabs the gin, the vermouth, some olives, mixes it up and tells you a worth that displays his negotiations with all his suppliers and his sense of native market circumstances, what he thinks you’ll be prepared to pay for a martini.

And he’s balancing all these issues and it’s like a straight line. You negotiate with the bar maintain, he offers with all people else. In 1919, Mr. Gower is in precisely the identical form of enterprise, besides as an alternative of gin and vermouth, he’s obtained large jars, filled with powders and okay, I imply, a kind of jars is marked poison. I’m unsure what that’s about, however, okay. Mr. Gower measures out doses and sells them to his clients at a worth he units. Identical precise deal. Easy.

Since then, a pair issues have occurred. First, scientific breakthroughs made medication a a lot larger deal. I imply, penicillin, insulin, the Polio vaccine, only for starters, it’s a miracle and an enormous enterprise.

The opposite factor is, medical health insurance turned a factor, together with pharmaceuticals. So now you’ve obtained this middleman standing between you and the supplier, hashing out costs, telling you what your share is gonna be. And people two issues created a possibility for a brand new form of enterprise: pharmacy profit managers.

Jeffrey Joyce is an economist on the College of Southern California. He research the drug provide chain. He says, initially these corporations did one slim, technical factor. They created programs that informed the drug retailer what every buyer’s particular insurance coverage plan meant that buyer was speculated to pay for his or her particular prescription, and the programs did all that in actual time.

Geoffrey Joyce: In order that whenever you present up on the pharmacy, it’s a seamless transaction and so they know precisely what your insurance coverage is and what your copay needs to be.

Dan: As a result of Mr. Gower is just not sending you a invoice. He must ring you up proper now. And insurance coverage corporations weren’t set as much as make that occur. So pharmacy profit managers, PBMs for brief, that’s what they got here alongside to do.

Geoffrey Joyce: That’s what they functioned primarily as for a lot of, a few years.

Dan: After which PBMs obtained this new thought. They stated to their clients, the insurance coverage corporations, Hey, we might prevent some cash. How about we begin negotiating with producers to get you decrease costs? Right here’s how that works. There’s a number of varieties of medication the place totally different corporations make their very own model. Like for prime ldl cholesterol, there’s medication known as statins, and so they’ve obtained model names like Lipitor, Mevacor, Crestor.

However all of them mainly do the identical factor. And that is a chance for the PBMs.

Geoffrey Joyce: They may go to the totally different producers and say, who’s gonna give us the perfect worth? Who desires to be our most popular statin?

Dan: And that most popular statin? That one’s gonna transfer lots of items as a result of the PBM and any insurance coverage firm they’re working for is gonna say to shoppers: For those who’re our affected person, our buyer lined by our insurance coverage, we wish you to take this statin and we’ll make it price your whereas cuz this one, the most popular statin has a $10 copay and all of the others 50 bucks, perhaps 75, perhaps we don’t cowl them in any respect. And immediately producers are coming to the desk.

Geoffrey Joyce: And producers supply reductions or rebates. So, hey, I’ll offer you 40 or 50% off for those who make mine the popular statin with a $10 copay. And all my rivals are both aren’t lined in your plan or have a $50 copay.

Dan: And right here’s an vital distinction. The producers aren’t reducing their sticker costs right here for whoever desires to purchase. They’re giving this rebate to this PBM. In different phrases, The PBM isn’t procuring. They’re not evaluating the costs on supply within the open market. They’re negotiating. They’re slicing particular person offers behind closed doorways, however no matter, okay. At first, to an economist like Jeffrey Joyce, this complete arrange feels like nice information.

Geoffrey Joyce: I purchased into their arguments that they really lowered costs by negotiating competitively and and with producers.

Dan: Now, sellers can’t simply cost no matter they need. They’ve gotta compete to offer the perfect deal to consumers. Everyone wins. It’s like economics 101.

Geoffrey Joyce: In, in, in concept, you’d need this kind of entity. You need them to go round and say, who’s gonna gimme the perfect worth?

Dan: However it hasn’t labored out that method, which is why Jeffrey Joyce revealed an essay final 12 months known as An Economist’s Change of Coronary heart.

Geoffrey Joyce: So as an alternative of type of serving a, a job of, of constraining drug costs, I feel they play a job in rising drug costs.

Dan: Yeah, wait… How can we go from their holding costs all the way down to their jacking costs up? That’s proper after this break.

This episode of An Arm and a Leg is produced in partnership with KFF Well being Information. That is a nonprofit newsroom overlaying well being care in America. Their work is terrific, I am so happy to work with them. We’ll have a bit extra details about KFF Well being Information on the finish of this episode.

So, how do pharmacy profit managers go from holding costs all the way down to jacking costs up? That is the place Mr. Gower and Nick the bartender are available in…

As soon as upon a time, earlier than penicillin, earlier than insurance coverage, earlier than pharmacy profit managers, the relationships had been easy. Me, Mr. Gower, his suppliers… straight line.

Now these relationships are a tangled knot. I discovered this tremendous difficult flowchart made by Jeffrey Joyce’s, colleagues from the College of Southern California. It’s from a paper known as Observe the Cash, besides the cash’s unattainable to observe.

There’s insurance coverage corporations, producers, pharmacies, cash going backwards and forwards. Far and wide. And on this knot, the pharmacy profit supervisor is in the midst of every thing. Each loop, all of the offers and all the cash, all of it goes via them.

Geoffrey Joyce: You’re proper. And so they’re the hub. You’re completely proper. And I feel that’s on the, the criminal of it. They’ve an inherent battle of curiosity.

Dan: That’s: Everyone’s gotta negotiate with them. The drug makers, the pharmacies, and the insurance coverage firm, and no person is aware of the deal anyone else is getting. So yeah, in concept, you’d need an entity just like the PBMs negotiating in your behalf. However that’s not what they’re doing. They’re negotiating on their very own behalf.

Geoffrey Joyce: And so they obtained sued, uh, in a number of states for saying, “Hey, try to be performing in the perfect curiosity of your purchasers.” And so they’ve gained in courtroom and saying, “No, now we have no obligation to do what’s finest for our shopper. We do what’s finest for us.”

Dan: Okay. So how does that work and the way does it result in greater costs? Properly, it helps. These corporations have gotten enormous. There was a bunch of PBMs, however they’ve gone round shopping for one another up. Now, three PBM corporations signify like 4 fifths of all shoppers. The only greatest one covers like 80 million individuals.

In order that they make an inventory of medication for these 80 million individuals, which medication value $10? Which of them value $50? And which of them. Aren’t lined in any respect. That record has a reputation. It’s known as the formulary, and controlling a formulary with 80 million clients provides the PBM a complete new form of leverage.

Geoffrey Joyce: Simply let me put it this fashion. Think about you’re a producer and also you produce a great drug and Categorical Scripts says, we signify 80 million Individuals of their drug advantages. For those who’re off our formulary as a producer, you lose entry to 80 million shoppers. That’s an unlimited hit. You’ll do something to remain on that formulary.

Dan: You’ll do something the PBM desires. And what the PBM desires is an enormous low cost and the devious, difficult wild half that Jeffrey Joyce taught me, the best approach to give an enormous low cost is jack up the sticker worth, which feels like it will by no means work. Like I do know. We’ll double the worth, then we are able to cost them the identical, however we’ll inform them they’re getting a 50% low cost. *nefarious snort*

I imply, are PBMs speculated to be silly? However PBMs aren’t silly. Keep in mind, they’re not procuring on the open market. They’re negotiating in secret, and so they’re not simply negotiating for reductions. They’re getting rebates, not cash off, a refund. A payout.

Geoffrey Joyce: It’s more cash that probably they’ll retain. Proper? So the extra, the larger the rebate, that’s cash. They’ve management over them.

Dan: It’s, it’s actually, it’s money of their pockets.

Geoffrey Joyce: It’s money.

Dan: And Joyce says, these negotiations get completely specific. Elevating costs is a part of the deal.

Geoffrey Joyce: And so I’ve had a number of CEOs of drug corporations inform me, PBMs put a gun to their head.

Increase your costs, i.e. increase your rebate, otherwise you’re off our formulary.

Dan: And naturally, doing enterprise in a again room someplace is what makes all this doable.

Geoffrey Joyce: All the pieces is, is proprietary. Nobody can see what sort of low cost or rebates they’re getting, and nobody actually is aware of how a lot is being retained and the way a lot is being handed on. And anytime you could have that lack of expertise and lack of readability, there’s, it’s it’s a ripe atmosphere for abuse and extra revenue.

Dan: There’s only one different factor, and I’m form of reluctant to inform you this cuz I’ve this rule in regards to the present the place it’s speculated to be extra entertaining and empowering and perhaps helpful than it’s enraging and terrifying and miserable. However I can not maintain again this half. So right here it’s:

That knot, that tangle of offers with cash going backwards and forwards and the PBMs in the midst of every thing.That knot is getting tighter. Cuz the gamers are merging with one another. These three large PBMs, one among them is CVS, the drug retailer chain, which can also be merging with an insurance coverage firm, Aetna, and the opposite two?

One belongs to an insurance coverage firm, and the opposite is getting purchased by one.

Geoffrey Joyce: They all the time argue there are economies of scale and synergies, et cetera. Traditionally, we’ve seen the shoppers lose whenever you see better and better focus inside an trade.

Dan: Nice. *exasperated sigh*

You already know what’s humorous? None of this fairly solutions the query I began with. Why had been there so many costs for that one generic prescription I attempted to fill? And it seems, Jeffrey Joyce has truly accomplished analysis on this slim little query, random costs on the drugstore. He despatched tons of of USC college students to drugstores in LA with pretend prescriptions to fill. His findings: My expertise was not a one-off. Not an accident.

Geoffrey Joyce: And it’s mainly the drug retailer or no matter saying, Hey, right here’s a shopper that will or might not know the worth, and we are able to cost them what we expect we are able to get away with.

Dan: So Mr. Gower remains to be with us, and he’s additionally making an attempt to make a buck nevertheless he can.

Geoffrey Joyce: You or your baby is sick and also you want an antibiotic. You’ve perhaps not used that antibiotic previously, or it’s been a very long time. You don’t know what the worth of that’s. You don’t know what an affordable worth is.

Dan: Your physician’s like, you want a Z-Pak.

Geoffrey Joyce: Precisely.

And whenever you stroll in, would you already know if a Z-Pak is, you already know, 100 {dollars}? That which may be the worth you don’t have any thought.

Dan: So mainly we gotta watch our backs with everybody, which is popping into form of a theme on this present. And typically I assume an outfit like GoodRx will help us know if Mr. Gower is making an attempt to place one over on us. And it gives reductions with these coupons it has. So I requested Jeffrey, Joyce, and the opposite consultants I talked with, how do I would like to look at my again with GoodRx?

I imply, there’s a catch proper? And so they stated, no, not precisely, besides that it’s, you already know, only a bandaid. It’s not altering something in regards to the large image with the PBMs and all the opposite gamers. In truth, when GoodRx exhibits us a coupon for a reduction, it’s as a result of they’ve made a take care of a pharmacy profit supervisor behind the scenes to get it.

So GoodRx wrangles its costs outta that very same loopy float chart, that very same loopy knot that produce the jacked up costs we see. And presumably it’s discovering a approach to make a revenue, but when a bandaid is helpful to you, I assume it’s helpful.

That’s the place we left issues 4 years in the past.

I wanna recap my large takeaway from that Journey: PBMs push drug makers to set greater record costs as a result of the upper the record worth goes, the larger the rebate, the money payout the PBMs can seize.

And right here’s a pair issues that we didn’t hit. By setting most popular medication based mostly on which firm provides ’em the largest rebates, and by making us pay tremendous excessive costs for anything. PBMs work with insurance coverage corporations to restrict entry to medication.

And if in case you have a excessive deductible, or a copay, or proportion of record worth you’re speculated to pay on the pharmacy counter, the PBM nonetheless will get their full rebate.

In different phrases, among the cash coming outta your pocket might go on to them.

Some issues have modified since we first put this story out. The most important PBMs have gotten larger. As an illustration, the largest, Categorical Scripts, now covers 100 million individuals, up from 80 million.

And the largest PBMs have been experimenting with new shenanigans — sufficient for at the very least a complete new episode.

However not all of the information is dangerous. In the previous couple of years, state legislatures have handed 150 legal guidelines trying to control PBMs. Each state has handed at the very least one.

Just a few states have handed legal guidelines saying that PBMs should move rebates alongside the shoppers on the pharmacy counter.

In different phrases, making an attempt to cease the PBMs from that state of affairs the place they’re getting cash immediately outta your pocket.

Couple different states have handed legal guidelines saying PBMs can not power you to make use of their mail order pharmacies, which nice, however geez, I assume meaning it’s authorized in 48 states and Congress has held 5 hearings thus far this 12 months particularly on PBMs with members from each events desperate to get their licks in.

I’m not saying that the cavalry or Congress is about to experience in and repair every thing. I want. However I’m saying, by understanding higher what’s happening, we are able to get a greater sense of what we wish our elected people to do. I’ll catch you in just a few weeks until then, maintain your self.

This episode of An Arm and a Leg was produced by me, Dan Weissmann, with assist from Emily Pisacreta and Bella Czajkowski. Whitney Henry-Lester edited this story in 2019, and Ellen Weiss edited this up to date model.

Daisy Rosario is our consulting managing producer. Adam Raymonda is our audio wizard. Our music is by Dave Winer and Blue Dot Periods.

Gabrielle Healy is our managing editor for viewers. She edits the First Help Package Publication.

Bea Bosco is our consulting director of operations. Sarah Ballema is our operations supervisor.

An Arm and a Leg is produced in partnership with KFF Well being Information.

That’s a nationwide newsroom producing in-depth journalism about well being care in America, and a core program at KFF — an impartial supply of well being coverage analysis, polling, and journalism.

Zach Dyer is senior audio producer at KFF Well being Information. He’s editorial liaison to this present.

Due to Public Narrative — That is a Chicago-based group that helps journalists and non-profits inform higher tales– for serving as our fiscal sponsor, permitting us to just accept tax-exempt donations. You possibly can be taught extra about Public Narrative at http://www.publicnarrative.org.

And because of all people who helps this present financially.

If you have not but, we would love so that you can be a part of us. The place for that’s armandalegshow.com/help.

Thanks for pitching in for those who can, and thanks for listening!

“An Arm and a Leg” is a co-production of KFF Well being Information and Public Street Productions.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here